Te Taumata drives pause on ETS review to allow for genuine Māori input

Te Taumata drives pause on ETS review to allow for genuine Māori input

On behalf of Māori forestry landowners, Te Taumata has voiced our concerns about the Government’s consultation process regarding the Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) review and the inclusion of exotics in the permanent category of the scheme.

We have today called for Climate Change Minister, James Shaw, to meet with Te Taumata kanohi ki te kanohi to discuss and agree on the detail regarding the next stages of the ETS review and Climate-change Policy Review.

This follows what we consider to be an attempt by Government officials to ‘tick-box’ consultation with Māori, by requiring us to sign an NDA to attend a ‘drop-in session’ about the ETS review, and giving us less than two working days to provide feedback.

While Te Taumata welcomed Government’s commitment to meeting the Crown’s obligations under Te Tiriti, we are seeking a fair opportunity to provide quality input into the proposed review, alongside key Māori forestry landowners and Iwi representatives.

We have significant concerns about the economic impact of the proposals in the scoping document on the Māori economy, Māori, and the national economy.

Unfortunately, our experience with Government and officials over the past two years regarding forestry has been driven by what appears to be a political agenda to exclude exotics from this category. 

This has prompted the development of a Te Taumata report reviewing the stated opposition to exotics in the Permanent Category of the ETS, with an evidence-based lens and feedback from a te ao Māori view.

Some of the report findings include:

  • Inclusion of exotics in the Permanent Category of the ETS is a necessary and complementary land use option, and opens the pathway for Māori to sustainably develop our land.
  • There is no substantive evidence that the risks of exotics in the Permanent Category equal the risks that have been attributed by officials.
  • An industry Code of Practice will address the concerns of Government and allow for the industry to self-regulate with the support of our Treaty partner, the Crown.
  • The Crown would benefit from working in partnership with Māori in the Forestry Value Chain.

Our recommendations are that:

  • Exotic forest species must remain a part of the permanent category in the ETS.
  • The ETS continues to recognise the carbon sequestration value of forestry within the ETS.
  • The Minister accepts our industry-led Code of Practice as the solution without the need to take further regulatory action.
  • The Minister agrees to work proactively, collaboratively, and in partnership, empowering Ngā Pou a Tāne.
  • The Minister makes officials aware that misrepresentation of the forestry industry is unacceptable.

We will continue to keep you updated as we progress this important kaupapa and mahi.



Canadian Council for Aboriginal Business

CCAB delivers programs that facilitate the growth of Indigenous business, build relationships between Indigenous and non-Indigenous business, and ensure life-long learning for Indigenous entrepreneurs, and other Canadian business leaders. These efforts recognise the central role that Indigenous business and communities hold in the future of Canada.
Our mission is to promote, strengthen and enhance a prosperous Indigenous economy through the fostering of business relationships, opportunities and awareness for all of our members.

Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade

The Ministry acts in the world to make New Zealanders safer and more prosperous.
E mahi ana te Manatū i te Ao kia whai haumaru me te whai rawa mo Aotearoa.
New Zealand’s security and prosperity depend on the conditions in, and our connections with, the wider world. This means we must engage with – and seek to influence – other countries to our advantage, in line with New Zealand’s values and interests including that of Maori.

New Zealand Trade and Enterprise

New Zealand Trade and Enterprise (NZTE) is the government agency charged with helping New Zealand businesses to grow internationally.
We use our extensive knowledge and global networks to help exporters of all sizes make better decisions and connect to the right partners and investors.
We connect international businesses and investors with high-value growth opportunities in New Zealand.
By supporting New Zealand businesses, we boost New Zealand's economy and reputation, and help to share what's special about New Zealand with the rest of the world.

Callaghan Innovation

We are New Zealand's innovation agency. We activate innovation and help businesses grow faster for a better New Zealand.
We partner with ambitious businesses of all sizes, providing a range of innovation and research and development (R&D) services to suit each stage of growth.
Our people – including more than 200 of New Zealand’s leading scientists and engineers – empower innovators by connecting people, opportunities and networks, and providing tailored technical solutions, skills and capability development programmes, and grants co-funding.

Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment

Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) plays a central role in shaping and delivering a strong New Zealand economy.
Our role is to create better outcomes for all New Zealanders, particularly by supporting business growth.
We are responsible for the delivery of advice, regulation and services that have a real impact on people, businesses and the environment within which they operate.